More of your customers will meet your products this holiday season through a chatbot, not a search results page or an Instagram post. They will ask an AI assistant for "a gift for a ten-year-old who loves science" and get a short list. Whether your store is on that list depends on things most independent retailers have never had to think about.
What happened
Adobe's 2026 holiday forecast, reported by Digital Commerce 360 on September 29, projects $275.1 billion in U.S. online holiday sales, up 6.7%. The more interesting number is about where shoppers come from. Adobe expects traffic to retail sites referred by AI tools to rise about 130% year over year, with the biggest jump on Thanksgiving. In an Adobe survey of 5,000 shoppers, 77% of those who had used AI for shopping said they felt more confident in their purchase, and 69% said they were less likely to return the item.
Big retailers have spent the year deciding how far to go. Retail Dive reported in January that Etsy, Target and Walmart expanded their listings to Google's Gemini and Microsoft's Copilot after joining ChatGPT in 2025. The same piece laid out the risks: when shopping starts and ends inside someone else's AI, the retailer loses the search and browsing data, and possibly the customer relationship. Wharton's Kartik Hosanagar put it simply: "Whoever controls the agents now has the power."
Smaller sellers have already felt the downside. CNBC reported in January on backlash against Amazon's "Buy for Me" tool from online retailers that did not want their websites scraped. A Virginia stationery shop said it learned it was in the program when orders arrived for a product it does not sell.
Why it matters for your business
For an independent store, AI shopping is both a threat and an opening.
The threat is invisibility. A chatbot does not scroll. It reads product data, reviews and descriptions, then picks a few options. If your product pages are thin, your prices are missing, or your stock status is wrong, you are not in the answer. And if a large marketplace scrapes your catalog and represents it badly, you may get orders, refunds and angry customers you never agreed to.
The opening is that AI assistants reward detail, not ad budget. A shop that writes clear, specific product descriptions, keeps inventory current and earns real reviews can show up next to much bigger names. Adobe's survey suggests shoppers who arrive this way are confident buyers who return less. That is the customer a small store wants.
The counterargument deserves a hearing. AI referrals are still a small share of most stores' traffic, and plenty of independents do fine on foot traffic, email and word of mouth. That is true. But growth rates like these compound, and the fixes that help with AI also help with ordinary search. There is little downside to doing them now.
What we'd do
- Rewrite your top 20 product pages. Plain language: what it is, who it is for, size, materials, what is in the box, price. Chatbots answer questions, so answer the obvious ones on the page.
- Keep stock and price accurate everywhere. Your site, Google Business Profile and any marketplace listings should match. Wrong data is how you end up recommended for something you cannot ship.
- Check who is listing your products. Search for your own store and best sellers in the major AI assistants. If a marketplace is reselling or misrepresenting you, find its opt-out and use it.
- Ask your platform what it offers. If you are on a hosted store platform, find out which AI shopping channels it already connects to and turn on the ones that let checkout happen on your own site.
- Collect reviews on more than one site. AI tools pull from many sources. A handful of honest reviews in several places beats a pile in one.
- Tag AI referrals in your analytics so you know by January whether this channel is real for you.
Our view: independents should treat AI assistants the way they treated Google a decade ago, as a front door they do not own but cannot ignore. Make your store easy for a machine to read, keep the checkout and the customer relationship on your own site, and say no to any program that sells your products without asking you first.
Want a system like this in your business?
A discovery conversation is where we map it: what to automate first, where the human checkpoints go, and what it would take.
Book a discovery conversation →